1. Purpose of the gate
Thesis accepted is the first commitment in the life of a chip startup, one of the cheapest and one of the most important: Thesis drafted, which opens the stage, only gives the idea time to be tested. Nothing has been signed and very little has been spent. What is at stake is the founders' time over the years a chip company takes to reach revenue, and the credibility of every claim they will later make to investors, partners and early hires. The gate asks whether the thesis is strong enough to justify that commitment.
A thesis is accepted when the problem is stated by potential customers in their own words rather than assumed, when conversations with potential buyers and users are recorded, when the market and competition have been sized from stated public sources with the assumptions written down, when there is no known reason the core idea cannot work, and when each founder's commitment and timing are stated. These are the gate criteria in the lifecycle, and the review should test each one rather than the general enthusiasm in the room.
Because founders run this review on themselves, the gate is easy to wave through. Its value comes from treating it as a real decision: writing down what was decided, what is still uncertain and what would make the founders change their minds. A thesis that cannot be written as a short, testable statement is not ready, however exciting the technology.
10 more sections for registered members.